Book review of I Will Repay

by Baroness Emma Orczy (Author)

Updated at: 24/02/2025

Baroness Orczy's I Will Repay, a thrilling sequel to The Scarlet Pimpernel, plunges readers into the tumultuous world of pre-revolutionary France. Chronologically the third book in the series, it follows Sir Percy Blakeney's adventures but begins years earlier in 1783. A seemingly insignificant duel between a wealthy gentleman, Paul Déroulède, and the impetuous Vicomte de Marny sets the stage for a story of honour, betrayal, and the looming shadow of the French Revolution. Orczy masterfully weaves a tale of escalating conflict, culminating in the terrifying uncertainty of 1793 Paris, where survival hinges on the unpredictable whims of the sans-culottes and the clandestine actions of the Scarlet Pimpernel.

4.4 / 461 ratings

Review I Will Repay

"I Will Repay," the sequel to the beloved "Scarlet Pimpernel," is a thrilling ride through the tumultuous backdrop of the French Revolution. While it doesn't quite reach the same heights of iconic status as its predecessor, it's a captivating story in its own right, offering a compelling blend of romance, suspense, and the ever-present shadow of the Scarlet Pimpernel himself.

Baroness Orczy masterfully weaves a tale of vengeance and unexpected love. The central conflict hinges on Juliette's oath to avenge her brother's death, an oath sworn to her grief-stricken and manipulative father. This sets up a fascinating dynamic with the brother's killer, the charming and somewhat hapless Paul Déroulède. Their relationship, fraught with tension and burgeoning affection, forms the emotional core of the novel. It's a slow burn, allowing the reader to witness the internal struggle of Juliette as she grapples with her duty and her growing feelings. This internal conflict is realistically portrayed, making Juliette a deeply sympathetic character despite her initially questionable actions.

The pacing is perhaps the book's most striking feature. Orczy keeps the tension high, creating a sense of urgency that mirrors the unpredictable nature of the Revolutionary period. The ever-present threat of the guillotine hangs heavy in the air, adding a layer of suspense that constantly keeps the reader on edge. There are moments of genuine nail-biting tension as Juliette and Déroulède navigate their perilous circumstances, cleverly avoiding the watchful eyes of the authorities.

While the Scarlet Pimpernel himself takes a step back from the forefront, his presence is still felt throughout the narrative. He's a subtle but powerful force, a beacon of hope in the darkness, offering glimpses of his cunning and bravery. His interventions, when they occur, are perfectly timed and incredibly effective, highlighting his unwavering commitment to justice and his capacity for both daring escapes and quiet acts of compassion. It's a testament to Orczy's skill that even with reduced screen time, Sir Percy remains an unforgettable presence, a symbol of unwavering hope.

However, some readers may find the book's focus on Juliette and Déroulède's personal struggles at the expense of broader action sequences, a departure from the more overtly adventurous nature of the original. This shift in focus isn't necessarily a drawback, but it does change the overall tone. The story is less about grand escapades and more about the intricate web of emotions and consequences woven by individual actions in a time of chaos.

In summary, "I Will Repay" is a worthy sequel, though perhaps not quite as immediately gripping as its famous predecessor. It shines in its exploration of character and its suspenseful plot, providing a nuanced look at love, loyalty, and revenge against the backdrop of historical turmoil. While some may yearn for more overt Scarlet Pimpernel action, the story stands firmly on its own merit, offering a rewarding and compelling read for fans of historical fiction and romance alike. The slower pacing allows for a deeper dive into the characters' internal struggles, adding a layer of complexity that elevates the story beyond a simple adventure tale. It's a book that lingers in the mind long after you turn the final page.